Key points
- A makeover changes what you see. A new kitchen changes everything, including the cabinets.
- If the cabinets are solid and the layout works, replacing them buys you very little.
- A makeover is fitted in 4 to 5 days. A full replacement takes far longer because of the rip-out and making good.
- Water-damaged units or a layout you dislike are the two honest reasons to start again.
What is the actual difference?
A new kitchen starts with a rip-out. Every cabinet comes off the wall, the worktops go in a skip, and the room is taken back to bare plaster. New cabinets are then built in, and the walls and services are made good around them.
A kitchen makeover leaves the cabinet boxes where they are. The doors, drawer fronts, worktops, end panels, handles and trims are replaced with new ones made to fit. From the front, you cannot tell the cabinets are not new, because every part you can see is.
| Makeover | New kitchen | |
|---|---|---|
| Cabinets | Kept | Replaced |
| Doors, worktops, handles | All new | All new |
| Layout | Stays the same | Can be changed |
| Rip-out and replastering | None | Usually needed |
| Time on site | 4 to 5 days | Weeks, as a rule |
| Cost | A fraction of a full replacement | The full price of a kitchen |
When is a makeover the better choice?
When the cabinets have life left in them. Cabinet boxes are simple things. If they are dry, square and firmly fixed, a new set would do the same job as the ones you have. Paying to replace them is paying for something nobody will ever see.
A makeover also suits you if you cannot face weeks without a kitchen. Because nothing is ripped out, there is no skip on the drive and no plasterer to wait for.
People often come to me after getting a price for a full kitchen and stopping short. They are not short of money. They just do not want to waste it.
When is a new kitchen the right answer?
A new kitchen is the right answer when the cabinets have failed, when you want a different layout, or when the kitchen was badly built in the first place. In those cases I will tell you a makeover is the wrong job.
- The cabinets have failed. Swollen sides, bases that have gone soft under the sink, units coming away from the wall.
- You want a different layout. Moving the sink to the window, adding an island, taking a wall out. A makeover does not replan the room.
- The kitchen was poorly built to begin with. New doors on units that were never level will only ever look as good as what is behind them.
If you are not sure which side of the line your kitchen falls, run through the checks in is my kitchen suitable for a makeover.
Does a makeover look like a compromise?
It should not. The doors are new doors, not a film or a wrap over the old ones. The worktops are new worktops. You choose the style and colour from samples, the same as you would for a full kitchen. Have a look at the before and after photos and judge for yourself.
What about the bits in between?
Not every kitchen needs the full makeover either. If the worktops are still good, replacement doors alone may do it. New worktops are fitted as part of a makeover. The guide on what a kitchen makeover costs explains how each choice moves the price.
How do you find out for certain?
Have someone look at the cabinets. I do that at a free home visit, anywhere from Worcester and Malvern to Tewkesbury. If a makeover will not work in your kitchen, I will say so there and then.